Thursday, January 22, 2009

Session 2

Focus Question- Management versus Leadership

First of all, I have to see if I understand correctly the difference between management and leadership. To put it in short terms, a manager makes sure everyone is doing their job, but it takes a leader to guide and improve performance. I see that they both are great to have, but I think schools have a lot of mangers, but not enough leaders. Not to say that having all the managers is bad, but leaders are good to have to promote growth and improve performance.
One example I have is that one school has a wonderful principal in which could stretch a dollar a mile long. Which means she is able to pull money out of thin air. Now by the definition given on the podcast I do not know what to consider this principal. She can be considered a leader because she is known for getting money for programs or equipment that she considers to be essential to improve learning. When I hear the would leader I imagine a person who suggest and encourages new ideas which are proven to improve performance. She gets the money needed to purchase the equipment, but others have to have the drive and motivation to present the ideas to her and then she chooses to buy or not to buy. That is what I thought of as a manager because when she does consider buying equipment, she tries to find the best cost effective way to get it, but not necessarily the best equipment on the market just to have the equipment to meet the status quo.
I have seen some teachers that have the leadership in them. One example I have is a teacher that has shown me hope in the growth of technology in learning. This teacher has taken any technology that he has and put it to use. For example, he got brand new alpha smarts this year. He read about them and learned all about them, but he didn't know how to set them up or how to run them. He showed interest and a drive I wish more teachers have for using technology. He asked me for help in which I was glad to do just that. Once I set up the lab and gave him a short lesson on the little information I knew about them, he took off with it. He took it home, played with the equipment while he was off track and came back with enough knowledge to be confident enough to use it in the classroom. This teacher was also one of the first to test an on-line program called Accelerated Math in our district, which he became the one who taught and guided other teachers to incorporate the program into the classroom. He even taught me how to use it. This trait is one I see in a leader.
Managers are ones who like to control the environment, but leaders are those who encourage and want to improve the environment and willing to do extra to help.

Activity Log-
1/20/09-
Listen to podcast, went to sleep to think of management and leadership
1/21/09- Observe principal and teachers. Think of examples of leadership and management.
1/22/09- Write the blog.
1/25/09-
Respond to fellow student blogs.

3 comments:

  1. Hey, Bill. Reading your post made me think about how managers are sometimes perceived. When I think of a manager, the first things that come to mind are controlling, rigid and only care about the outcome. I think I have formulated these traits as a first response, because often times people chose the management role when the group needs a leader. As I think about that, bad managers are the cause of this perception. Managers, acting appropriately, are a precious asset to an organization. Thanks for making me think.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe you have accurate assessments of what the principal and teacher was. A leader tends to go above and beyond to make change. It seems that the teacher was definitely a leader because they were willing to take the alpha smarts home and use their own free time to fully understand the technology. In contrast, the principal was more of a manager because they were more interested in saving money vs. really jumping at the potential educational benefits this new technology could provide, no matter the cost.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well,I missed your name being added to the blog list. Sorry about that. I think you can see we all said pretty much the same thing about our topic this week. It seems that most feel a lot of people can be trained to be a good manager but it takes something intrinsic to make a person a leader.

    ReplyDelete